|
Rationale for supporting the General
Assembly's regret for the institution and lasting affects of
slavery.
A JOINT RESOLUTION expressing the general assembly's
profound regret for the institution and lasting effects of slavery.
(click this link to read the two page resolution)
I believe my
decision to support the resolution was the correct decision for a
variety of reasons. While we are individuals representing citizens
who are alive today, we are also part of an institution whose past
members' decisions are woven into the fabric of the General
Assembly’s legacy. This legacy has many threads that are truly acts
of greatness, but it also has some for which no reasonable person
could be proud. This resolution acknowledges past mistakes and
frees us to move on.
The following
summarizes my perspective on concerns raised by some citizens who
criticized the decision to support the resolution.
On this being a slippery slope to reparations
This measure
does not obligate legislative members to provide reparations. A
subset of the democrat majority has never ceased to propose
legislation that is de facto reparations and they will continue to
do so as long as they are in the majority. Federal and State
governments have redistributed trillions of dollars of wealth over
the years by funding programs that are at least in part driven by
their belief that we should provide additional reparations. I
believe there are several conservative democrats who are prepared
join Republicans in OPPOSITION to measures that propose new
entitlements and reparations. However, a vote against the
resolution would most likely eliminate any chance that we would to
get support from more conservative members of the democrat party
members to oppose such measures. Consider the likelihood that 9 or
more democrats would join Republicans in an attempt to oppose
reparations measures if their leadership and their democrat
colleagues openly attack Republicans for opposing it?
On the notion that current members should not or can not apologize
for wrong decisions of past members
President Ronald
Reagan signed the Civil Liberties Act of 1988, which apologized for
Japanese American Internment (which began in 1942) during World War
II. The following
is an excerpt from the 1988 federal act…
“The Congress recognizes that, as described in the Commission on
Wartime Relocation and Internment of Civilians, a grave injustice
was done to both citizens and permanent residents of Japanese
ancestry by the evacuation, relocation, and internment of civilians
during World War II ... The excluded individuals of Japanese
ancestry suffered enormous
damages, both material and intangible, and there were incalculable
losses in education and job training, all of which resulted in
significant human suffering ... For these fundamental
violations of the basic civil liberties and constitutional rights of
these individuals of Japanese ancestry, the Congress apologizes on
behalf of the Nation.”
President Reagan thought is was appropriate for Congress to
apologize for past members on behalf of a Nation, and I believe the
current members of the NC General Assembly can apologize on behalf
of past members of the General Assembly. |